You're exploring a preview — try it just like a student would. Nothing you type is saved.

Arid landscape with a small concrete structure.
Photo: Jay Heike / Unsplash
Earth & Space Science

Oklahoma Used to Get 2 Earthquakes a Year — Then Suddenly It Got 903

Reading Level ·MS-ESS3-2·Oklahoma Used to Get 2 Earthquakes a Year — Then Suddenly It Got 903

In the United States, most earthquakes happen along the West Coast, especially in California, because of major fault lines in Earth's crust. Oklahoma, in the middle of the country far from any major fault line, historically had almost none. From the 1970s through 2008, Oklahoma averaged only about 2 earthquakes of magnitude 3.0 or greater per year.

Then the numbers started climbing. In 2009, Oklahoma recorded 20 earthquakes. By 2010, there were 42. The count jumped to 109 in 2013, then exploded to 585 in 2014. In 2015, Oklahoma hit 903 earthquakes, making it the most seismically active state in the continental United States — surpassing California. The largest event, a magnitude 5.8 earthquake near Pawnee on September 3, 2016, was felt across seven states.

When scientists mapped the earthquakes, they noticed a striking pattern. The quakes were not spread randomly across the state. Instead, they clustered near high-volume wastewater disposal wells used by the oil and gas industry. These wells inject large amounts of wastewater deep underground. Researchers found that earthquake frequency tracked closely with the volume of wastewater being injected into these deep wells.

The injected wastewater increases pore pressure — the pressure of fluid inside tiny spaces in underground rock. This added pressure pushes against existing fault lines that had been stable for thousands of years, reducing friction until the faults slip and produce an earthquake.

Key Science Idea · Analogy

Imagine pushing a heavy box across the floor. The box stays still because friction holds it in place. Now imagine someone squirts slippery soap under the box. The soap reduces the friction, and the box suddenly slides. That is similar to what happens underground. Fault lines are cracks in rock that stay locked in place because of friction. When wastewater is pumped deep underground, it seeps into tiny spaces in the rock and pushes outward. This added pressure — called pore pressure — acts like the soap. It reduces friction on the fault until the rocks suddenly slip, causing an earthquake.

man in gray long sleeve shirt and pants standing beside cardboard boxes
man in gray long sleeve shirt and pants standing beside cardboard boxesAustrian National Library / Unsplash

In 2015 and 2016, the Oklahoma Corporation Commission ordered oil and gas companies to reduce the volume of wastewater injected at disposal wells in affected areas. The earthquake rate responded. By 2017, the count dropped to 304. By 2019, it was down to 81. The decline in earthquakes roughly matched the reduction in injection volume, reinforcing the connection scientists had identified in the data.

Key Science Idea · Before / During / After
Before (1970s–2008): Oklahoma's underground faults are stable. Very little wastewater is injected nearby. Pore pressure is low, friction holds the faults locked, and the state averages about 2 earthquakes per year.
During (2009–2015): Oil and gas activity increases and large volumes of wastewater are pumped into deep disposal wells. Pore pressure rises on nearby faults, reducing friction. Faults begin slipping. Earthquake counts climb from 20 to 903 per year.
After (2016–2019): Regulators order companies to reduce injection volumes. Pore pressure drops, friction on faults increases again, and earthquake counts fall — from 623 in 2016 to 81 in 2019.
Causal Chain

Try a different CER version

CER Statement to Evaluate
Claim

Oklahoma's earthquake surge was caused by hydraulic fracturing (fracking) cracking underground rock and creating new fault lines where none previously existed.

Evidence

The passage states that oil and gas industry activity was occurring in Oklahoma when earthquakes increased dramatically. Earthquake counts rose from about 2 per year to 903 during a period of heavy oil and gas operations in the state.

Reasoning

Hydraulic fracturing fractures deep rock formations to extract oil and gas, and this process creates new fault lines in previously stable rock. Once these new faults are created, they become sites of seismic activity, explaining Oklahoma's sudden spike in earthquakes.

Stage 1: Read & Identify
Question 1 of 4

Which part of the CER statement is the claim — the testable explanation of the phenomenon?